New Thermodynamics: Pictet, Epistemology and Philosophy
Abstract
Pictet’s experiment was front and center in the 18th/19th century debate concerning whether heat is a wave, or a particle. Pictet’s experiment is best understood by realizing that thermal radiation energy plays a significant role in heat transfer. It is argued that this readily ignored experiment should have long ago alerted us to issues concerning our understanding of thermodynamics.
This questions the rationale behind modern statistical thermodynamics, which describes all of a gaseous system’s energy purely in terms of the kinematics of that system’s gas. Not only is the philosophy of statistical mechanics now questioned but so too are those associated with entropy and its mathematical accomplice the second law.
After raising questions, a simpler explanation as to what is witnessed will be discussed. An explanation that relegates statistical mechanics to a valid approximation for sufficiently dilute closed systems of gas, such as those often used in experiments. An explanation that remains void of the mathematical simplifications that statistical mechanics provides.
Ultimately, the accepted epistemology of our sciences will be verbally challenged.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Pimpas, Alexander, V., Mihova, Gergana M., Andreeva, Andreana I., Zografov, Nikolay,N. 2017.“Trapping Radiant Cold via Mirrors” Journal of Physics and Technology Vol 1 Number 2 pp 65-69]
Evans, James, Popp, Brian, 1985. “Pictet’s Experiment: The Apparent Radiation and Reflection of Cold”. Am. J. of Phys., 53(8): 737-753 (1985).
Mayhew, K.W., 2021. “New Thermodynamics: Inelastic Collisions, Lost Work, and Gaseous Inefficiency” Hadronic Journal, 44, pg 67-96
Tilley D.E., 1979. Contemporary College Physics Benjamin Cummings Publishing Don Mills, Ont. Canada 1979
Lambert F.L., 2002. “Entropy is simple, qualitatively”. J. Chem. Educ 79 187
Atkins , P,. 2007. Four laws that drive the universe Oxford University Press Oxford England 2007
Mayhew, K.W., 2022. “New Thermodynamics: The Second Law Buried by Illusions” Hadronic Journal 45, 97-116
Mayhew, K.W., 2015. “Entropy an ill-conceived mathematical contrivance” Phys. Essays 28 vol 3, 352
https://thestandupphilosophers.co.uk/what-is-entropy/
Ben-Naim, A., 2008. A Farewell to Entropy: Statistical Thermodynamics Based on Information. World Scientific Publishing Co., London, New York 2008
Ben-Naim, A., 2012. Entropy and the Second law: Interpretations and miss-Interpretations world scientific Publishing Co. London, New York, 2012
Mayhew, K.W., 2020. “New Thermodynamics: Reversibility and Free Energy” Hadronic Journal 43, 51-59
https://mathoverflow.net/questions/403036/john-von-neumanns-remark-on-entropy (Sept. 2022)
http://hockeyschtick.blogspot.com/2014/11/scientist-proved-214-years-ago-that.html#:~:text=THE%20HOCKEY%20SCHTICK%3A%20 Scientist%20proved,hot%20body%20hotter%2C%20proved%20opposite (Aug. 2022)
Capek, V., Sheehan D. P., 2005. Challenges to the second law of thermodynamics, Springer Press, Netherlands 2005
Hatsopoulos, George, Beretta, Gian Paolo. 2008. “Where is the entropy challenge?” AIP Conference Proceedings. 1033. 34. 10.1063/1.2979057.
Nikulov, A., 2022. “The Law of Entropy increase and the Meissner Effect”, Entropy, 24(1), 83
https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/947685-the-law-that-entropy-always-increases-holds-i-think-the
Mayhew, K.W., 2021. ”New Thermodynamics: Inelastic Collisions, Lost Work, And Gaseous Inefficiency”, Hadronic Journal, 44, (1)
Mayhew, K.W., 2020 “New thermodynamics: Illusions of Elastic Collisions in the Sciences”, EJERS, Vol. 5, 1, pg 87-93
Mayhew, K.W. 2021. “New Thermodynamics: Inelastic Collisions, Lost Work and Gaseous Inefficiency. Hadronic Journal vol. 44 (1), pg. 67-97
Mayhew, K.W., 2015. “Second law and lost work”, Phys. Essays 28, vol. 1¸152
Mayhew, K.W., 2020 “New Thermodynamics: Inefficiency of a Piston-Cylinder”, EJERS Vol 5, 2, pg 187-191
D. Sheehan, 1998. “Four Paradoxes Involving the Second Law of Thermodynamics” J. Sci. Exploration, 12 (2), 303
Mayhew, K.W., 2021. “New Thermodynamics: Wave-Particle Duality in Radiative Heat Transfer” Hadronic Journal 44, 215-226
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molecular_chaos Oct., 2021
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photon_gas#Isothermal_transformations Dec., 2022
Mayhew, K.W., 2017. “A New Perspective for Kinetic Theory and Heat Capacity”, Prog. in Phys., Vol. 13 (4), pg 166-173
Mayhew, K.W., 2018. “Kinetic Theory: Flatlining of Polyatomic Gases”, Prog. in Phys., Vol. 14 (2), pg 75-79
Hartmann C., “On the 150th birthday of Max Planck: On Honesty towards nature” https://21sci-tech.com/translations/Planck% 20150th%20birthday-Nov.%2014.pdf
Santilli, R., M.., 2021. “Overview of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Argument with Applications in Physics, Chemistry and Biology” APAV
Mayhew, K.W., 2013 “Latent Heat and Critical Temperature: A Unique Perspective”. Phys. Essays 26,4. pg 604-611
Mayhew, K.W, 2020. New Thermodynamics: Untangling Entropy’s Web, Includes treatise on Global Warming (self-published book)
Mayhew, K.W., 2021 “New Thermodynamics: Questioning Temperature in Open systems, e.g., In Atmospheric Physics”. Hadronic Journal vol 44 (1), pg. 431-444
Allmendinger, T., 2016. “Thermal Behaviour of Gases Under the Influence of Infrared Radiation” Int. J of Phys. Sci. Vol 11 (15) pg 183- 205
Allmendinger, T., 2018. “Thermal Radiation of the Atmosphere and Its Role in the So-called Greenhouse Effect” Atm. And Cli Sci. Vol 8, 2
https://www.mofa.go.jp/policy/environment/warm/cop3/joint_2.html (Sept. 2022)
Mayhew, K.W., 2022. “New Thermodynamics: Rethinking the Science of Climate Change”, EJERS, Vol. 5, 5, pg. 569-564
Mayhew, K.W., 2021. “New Thermodynamics: How Mankind’s Use of Energy Influences Climate Change” Hadronic Journal 45 (4), 399-421
Seim, T.O. and Olsen B.T., 2020.“Unexpected relationships between thermal and radiative Energy Transfer” Atm and Clim, Sci. vol 10 no 2, pg 639-651
Gold, T. 1989. “New Ideas in Science” J.of Sci. Exploration Vol 3 No 2 pp 103-112
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.23756/sp.v11i1.1037
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
Copyright (c) 2023 Kent William Mayhew
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Science & Philosophy - Journal of Epistemology, Science and Philosophy. ISSN 2282-7757; eISSN 2282-7765.